Melinda French Gates created Pivotal Ventures in January 2015 with so little fanfare that news of the effort came out after GeekWire accidentally stumbled upon its website. At the time, a spokesperson for the Kirkland, Wash.-based company described it as “a vehicle, when the time comes, to help explore potential other initiatives that don’t fit naturally or neatly within the [Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation’s] program areas.”
It seems that time may have come.
Following her split with Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, observers are now eager to see where French Gates will take Pivotal, an organization promoting initiatives that empower women and families. Given her resources, drive and expertise, French Gates — who revived her maiden name in the wake of the divorce announcement earlier this month — could be a game-changing force in female-focused venture capital and philanthropic efforts.
“There is so much research about how difficult it is for women to raise funding for venture capital,” said Emily Cox Pahnke, an associate professor with the University of Washington’s Foster School of Business.
“What Pivotal could potentially do is shift the calculus where it’s not a liability to be a female,” she said. “That has transformational potential.”
When the teams of divorce lawyers are done divvying up the almost unimaginable wealth acquired by the Gateses during their 27-year marriage, both will walk away with tremendous sums. One can’t split $146 billion, using some measure of fairness, without that being the case.
And while the couple says they’ll continue working peaceably at the Gates Foundation, their roles unchanged at what many call the world’s most important philanthropy, both have independent passion projects launched years ago.
Before news of the divorce broke, Bill Gates was drawing headlines for his work on climate change, which he’s tackling through his Breakthrough Energy organization and a book on the topic.
Less attention has been paid to Pivotal, the investment and incubation company that’s French Gates’ primary side gig. French Gates has already made women’s equity a key focus at the Gates Foundation and experts say the organization is one of the most powerful players in the space. But Pivotal is hers alone to direct and includes the VC element for exploring broader avenues for impact.
“I want to see more women in the position to make decisions, control resources, and shape policies and perspectives,” French Gates wrote in a 2019 editorial in Time. “I believe that women’s potential is worth investing in — and the people and organizations working to improve women’s lives are, too.”
Possibility of upending VC inequities
Pivotal operated quietly at first, but French Gates has been promoting the company’s efforts more publicly in recent years. In the Time editorial, she committed to spending $1 billion over a decade in order to expand “women’s power and influence in the United States,” calling out Pivotal’s role in the effort. Also that year, her U.S.-focused company started making investments in ventures that are women-led, address family and women’s issues, or both.
Experts see tremendous social and economic benefits if French Gates ramps up these efforts. Last year, companies with female-only founders received a scant 2.3% of the venture capital awarded worldwide, reported Crunchbase — a decline from the previous year.
Top tier VC firms such as Sequoia Capital and Kleiner Perkins raise about $1 billion every five years for investing, Cox Pahnke said. French Gates could potentially operate at that level, boosting the percentage of capital directed at female entrepreneurs.
So far at least, Pivotal doesn’t appear to have been writing massive VC checks. The company has made seven investments in six different companies or nonprofits since March 2019. It was one of multiple investors in rounds that ranged from $700,000 to $34.5 million total, with most on the smaller side; the amount of Pivotal’s contributions were not disclosed.
Looking at the funding recipients gives a sense of the broad range of issues French Gates is interested in tackling and her holistic view. Recipients include:
- Till Financial, a platform for helping kids learn about savings and banking.
- Neolth, a startup providing mental health care for students.
- All Raise, an organization supporting female startup founders.
- AAKOMA Project, an effort to help racially diverse teens with mental health issues; Pivotal was the sole investor for the round and the amount was not publicized.
- Papa, a platform connecting older people with students to combat isolation in seniors, received funding from Pivotal in two rounds.
- Ellevest, a platform to help women invest their money.
Pivotal also recently partnered with Techstars to create the Future of Longevity Accelerator, a program that backs startups building products and services for caregivers. The accelerator announced its first cohort in September.
One of the important benefits of venture capital is the validation of business concepts and mentoring that comes from the investors. French Gates has access to a deep bench of health and social-issue knowledge held by current and former employees of the Gates Foundation.
“Given Melinda French Gates’ expertise and the team that she has assembled, they can be a source of capital that can change the game,” said Cox Pahnke.
Whether or when Pivotal will ramp up its investing is unknown; the company declined to make anyone available to comment for this story.
Evolving female focus
In her 2019 book on women’s empowerment, French Gates spoke about her formative experiences with women in low-income countries around the world, as well as her own challenges at Microsoft, where she started working in 1987. She was the only woman in the first class of MBAs hired by the software company.
French Gates left Microsoft in the late 1990s when her first child was born, and soon after began taking a more active role in the family’s philanthropic efforts, which had not yet coalesced into the foundation. One of her early programs to get computers into U.S. schools was driven in large part by her desire to get girls excited about technology. Another early initiative was promoting contraceptives globally, a healthcare tool that she embraced for her own family planning.
Fantastic to have @melindagates back on the Microsoft campus today to talk about her new book, #MomentofLift. It was a powerful and timely conversation about the importance of lifting up women to lift up all of humanity. It was inspiring to hear her stories and insights. pic.twitter.com/qsDzyAwNC8
— Satya Nadella (@satyanadella) May 10, 2019
As the Gates Foundation was taking shape in 2000, the Gateses shifted away from contraceptives and the controversy that came with them, including criticisms from the Catholic church. They focused on vaccines and other global health initiatives supporting low-income countries. But in 2012 French Gates, herself a Catholic, returned to contraceptives.
“Contraceptives are the greatest life-saving, poverty ending, women-empowering innovation ever created. When we saw the full power of family planning, we knew that contraceptives had to be a higher priority for us,” French Gates wrote in her 2019 book “The Moment of Lift.”
She also came to recognize that family planning was just a first step in her advocacy for women. In 2014, she doubled-down on a female-centered programs at the foundation. French Gates wrote an article for Science spelling it out: “We will systematically increase our focus on women’s specific needs and preferences and on addressing gender inequalities and empowering women as a way to help our partners succeed and us achieve our mission of helping all people to lead healthy, productive lives.”
But even with the Gates Foundation’s efforts, philanthropic support for women-focused nonprofits still lags behind other areas. Only 2.3% of the nearly $102 billion in gifts from private donors globally went to nonprofits addressing women’s issues in 2018, and most of those were targeting reproductive health, according to research by Candid.
Pivotal officially promotes efforts to “advance social progress” — and it clearly sees supporting women and families as an expedient way to do that. It gives out grants as well as VC investments, and while publicly available information is limited, it appears that the organization has dispersed more money in the form of gifts.
Pivotal has also funded research efforts in some of the company’s focus areas — a strategy that’s also embraced by the Gates Foundation, letting data shape grant making in order to maximize impact.
Most notably, in 2018 Pivotal teamed up with McKinsey & Co. to release the Rebooting Representation report, which examined the reasons why women, and particularly women of color, are underrepresented in technology jobs. Pivotal additionally created the Reboot Representation Tech Coalition that includes Microsoft, Google, Dell and others to address the challenge. The group set a goal of doubling the number of Black, Latinas and Native American women earning computing degrees by 2025, guided by their research results.
“Melinda’s superpower has been to garner incredible research to inform where we invest in solving some of these really big, intractable problems,” Lauren Sato, CEO of Seattle’s Ada Developers Academy. “And so I’m super excited for her to have more resources, more space to really double down on that work.”
Sato’s organization has used the Rebooting Representation report to guide some of the decisions at Ada, which provides free tech training for women and gender expansive adults.
Pivotal’s other projects and investments include:
- The Equality Can’t Wait Challenge, a contest launched in June that will award $40 million to organizations that expand women’s power and influence. MacKenzie Scott, who divorced Amazon’s Jeff Bezos, is contributing to the effort. Ada is one of the finalists for the challenge.
- A $50 million gift announced in March going to the Gender Equality in Tech Cities initiative, a program that supports women and racial diversity in technology.
- Investments beginning in 2016 that total more than $65 million to support federal paid-leave policy, with funds directed to policy centers and organizations campaigning for the cause.
- Additional efforts focus on mental health for young people, supporting women running for public office, and other equality-focused programs.
Scott has earned praise for her philanthropic generosity, giving away more than $5 billion last year to a variety of organizations. She signed The Giving Pledge — a pact made by ultra wealthy individuals to give away the majority of their wealth in their lifetimes — which the Gateses originally created along with billionaire investor Warren Buffett. The pledge, which Bezos has not signed, may be helping drive her giving.
But there are notable differences between Scott and French Gates. When Scott and Bezos parted ways, they did so without a prominent joint foundation in place. Scott didn’t have a company akin to Pivotal Ventures that could be scaled up to facilitate her giving and investing. While Scott has been largely cheered for her efforts, her lack of a foundation has made it easier for criminals to impersonate her and scam people out of thousands of dollars with false promises that Scott would be writing them checks, as was reported in The New York Times.
French Gates has been acting on her philanthropic passions for years, honing her voice and building her team. The question now is where she chooses to concentrate her attention as she’s untethered from Bill Gates.
“She’s been saying the things that really matter to her quietly for some time,” Sato said, “and so we’re super excited for her to get loud.”